Crave Cookies In Newton NJ: Viral Cookies Hit New Jersey

We pulled up for the grand opening, and trust me, the hype was real. People were lining up, everyone walking out with those signature boxes stacked high. We grabbed a half-dozen so we could get a full sweep of the menu, and honestly, not a single cookie missed.

The Caramel Apple Pie Cookie was the first one we cracked open — stuffed with real caramel and layered with apple and warm spice. It tastes like someone folded an apple pie into a cookie. Then came the Chocolate Lava Cookie, which literally poured out rich molten chocolate the second we split it in half. If you’re someone who loves that dramatic, gooey center moment, this one is your superstar.

But the cookie that surprised us most? The Oreo Churro Cookie. It’s crunchy, soft, cinnamon-sugary, and filled with Oreo goodness — hands down one of the most creative cookies we’ve tried this year. And for the fall-flavor lovers, the Pumpkin Coffee Cake Cookie deserves its own fanclub. It hits that perfect balance of cozy, warm spice with that crumbly coffee-cake texture on top.

And of course, they had to include their viral icon: the Craved Chocolate Chip. There’s a reason this one blew up the internet. It’s thick, melty, perfectly sweet, and basically everything you want a chocolate chip cookie to be. No extras needed — just pure cookie perfection.

One thing we didn’t expect? The loaded sodas. Sweet, fizzy, colorful, and surprisingly the perfect match for a warm, heavy cookie. It adds that refreshing balance so you can keep going without tapping out from sweetness overload.

Craved Cookies brings something new to Newton — a dessert spot that’s fun, indulgent, and unapologetically extra. Whether you’re local, passing through Sussex County, or planning a little dessert road trip, this place is worth the stop. Gooey centers, crispy edges, wild flavors, and that fresh-out-of-the-oven warmth… it’s cookie heaven, and it’s officially here.

Watch Full Video